Raise Minimum Wage = Higher Unemployment


images-28
Dear Mr. Market:

One of the greatest things about this country is that we are all free and entitled to voice our own opinions.  In this forum, however, we rarely intend to bring up political divisions as there are simply too many and we find very little upside in wasting our energy in that department.  Certain issues, however, have a direct economic impact to you and we believe those are worth digging into. The most recent debate over raising the minimum wage has certainly “ripped the Band-Aid” off an old but existing economic wound.  Taking all feelings and intuitively good intentioned emotions aside, let’s set the economic record straight on this hotly debated topic.

Currently Congressional Democrats want to raise the current minimum wage from $7.25 (nationally) up to $10.10/hour and also index it to the Consumer Price Index (CPI). With a Republican-led House this is unlikely to happen as they believe most businesses would have to cut jobs. Supporters of wage increases claim that the standard of living rises, poverty levels drop, and businesses become more efficient. The opposing side counters with claims of increased poverty, higher unemployment, and detrimental effects to most businesses. Who is right when it comes down to pure economics?

At a first glance raising the minimum wage obviously seems fair and just. Most people initially want that and so do unions who dislike low-cost labor competition. Clearly a full-time worker making the minimum wage is likely to be well under the poverty level. (family of 4 = $23,550 ) Over half of the minimum wage population is well under the age of 25. The majority of individuals in this population are unlikely to be supporting a family of four and in all likelihood are working their first job.

If it was just about picking a number and raising the wage to one that seems or “feels” right we ought to just go with $20/hour, right? Picking a random number or one that works backward to solve an economic problem won’t solve anything. In economics it comes down to basic realities like supply and demand, cause and effect etc. $20/hour seems a lot more “fair” than $10/hour but realistically when setting prices they must be derived from demand and economic data instead of grabbing them from thin air or what feels right.

The most famous economic study that supports raising the minimum wage is from 1992 by Card & Krueger. (David Card and Alan Krueger) These two economists surveyed fast food franchises in the New Jersey area before and after a minimum wage increase of 18.8% ($4.25/hour to $5.05/hour). Their studies showed that employment actually increased. Why was that and should proponents of raising the minimum wage really balance their main argument on this famous study?

Like any study you must be aware of what went into it, not just the well written conclusion! As we all should know (but few realize) numbers and statistics can be delivered to show almost any result the “researcher” wants. We’re not pointing fingers or calling anyone names but always be aware of the old adage: ”Figures don’t lie but liars can figure”.

In the case of the Card and Krueger study it only looked at one instance of change and focused on only one industry. They looked at the fast-food industry but only surveyed certain franchises (like the typical Burger King, McDonalds, or Taco Bell). Those names are huge chains and not reflective of who really gets stung. Think about your local Mom & Pop restaurant or neighborhood deli. Independent operations like this are far more labor intensive and cannot handle economic ripples as easily as a huge fast-food chain. An example of this is with the immense amount of prep work needed in these establishments; vegetables and buns are pre-sliced instead of by labor forces in the store.

If you don’t want to mind-wrestle with the economic equilibrium points or elasticity reactions…just think of yourself as a business owner.  Assume you pay your employees in a range depending on experience but on average it’s $10/hour. You are also saddled with trying to provide health insurance to your employees, which is another topic all on its own. The minimum wage increases to $9/hour and your temporary workers naturally want an increase too. Those who have more experience or tenure with you are going to want the same (if not more). What basically happens is that your entire wage scale is pushed up forcing you to make immediate decisions. It comes down to more than working harder, passing on costs to the client, or being more efficient. Nothing really happens to your highly paid workers but ironically enough it’s the ones who need it the most (lower paid) that are most vulnerable to get cut out completely! To stay in business most business owners simply cut hours and jobs.

What most people don’t realize is the end result of a policy change doesn’t always deliver the intended results. If you think it’s hard to live on $10.10/hour…you’re right. What’s even harder though is losing that job and going to $0.00/hour. The reality of workers being cut in this range is simply factual. The other unintended consequence is that if wages increase within this sector of the work force there isn’t the intended economic boost of stimulus that you would think. When businesses have to pay more for wages they then invest less elsewhere and that more than offsets the mild stimulus that the increased wage earners would theoretically bring.

We won’t bore you with footnotes or attachments to piles of past economic studies on this topic. If you’re truly curious simply look them up! If you want to save some time what you’ll undoubtedly learn is that raising the minimum wage will help a few people but overall unemployment actually increases! On average a 10% increase in wages leads to a 1% reduction in employment. President Obama’s current proposal calls for a 24% increase. Do the math… In summation, with any hotly debated topic there will be passionate opinions and surveys but one must always be aware of the facts (or lack thereof) and the long lasting effects. 

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s